top of page

BEFORE YOU INVEST IN AI: Is Your Hardwood Business Ready?

Writer: NHLA
NHLA
Nov 10
4 min read

BEFORE YOU INVEST IN AI: Is Your Hardwood Business Ready?

The technology may be ready. The more important question is whether it will improve a decision enough to justify the cost, complexity, and organizational change.


Is your hardwood business ready to invest in AI? Explore how sawmills and wood products manufacturers can evaluate artificial intelligence, automation, and advanced analytics by examining operational readiness, implementation costs, measurable returns, and workforce needs before committing to new technology.

At the NHLA Annual Convention in Cleveland in September, I heard both interest and caution about artificial intelligence (AI), automation, and advanced analytics. The conversations reflected a familiar reality: technology is moving quickly while investment decisions compete with difficult markets, workforce limitations, legacy equipment, and capital needs. Under those conditions, “Can AI do this?” may not be the best initial question. A better question may be whether AI technology can improve a defined decision enough to justify investment.


AI and advanced analytics are already being used across the forestry and wood products industry through machine vision, lumber grading, predictive maintenance, inventory management, production planning, and logistics. Some can improve yield, consistency, safety, or efficiency. Others may be technically impressive and still offer little practical value for a particular operation.


START WITH THE BUSINESS DECISION

A company doesn’t need to decide whether it is broadly “AI-ready.” That question is too abstract to be useful. Instead, companies should start with the decision or operating problem they need to improve.


Is the objective to improve grading consistency, reduce downtime, increase recovery, identify defects, forecast demand, or strengthen inventory control? Who makes that decision now? What information is used? How well does the current process perform? What does an error cost, and what level of improvement would matter?


Those questions establish a baseline without which there may be no defensible way to determine later whether the technology created value.


AI HAS TO BE BETTER THAN THE ALTERNATIVE

New technology should not be presumed better because it is new. AI s no exception, and should therefore be compared with realistic alternatives, including better calibration, improved sensing, process redesign, existing software, conventional statistical tools, employee training, or experienced human judgment.


In some cases, AI will provide capabilities that simpler approaches cannot. In others, a modest operational change may solve most problems at lower cost and with less disruption. Choosing the simpler option does not mean a company is falling behind. It means the company evaluated the technology against the business problem rather than adopting the technology for its own sake.


READINESS IS OPERATIONAL, NOT ABSTRACT

A successful demonstration may show that a given technology can work under test conditions; it does not establish that it will perform the same way in routine hardwood operations. Data may be incomplete, older and newer equipment may not communicate, outputs may arrive too late to improve the intended decision, or critical knowledge may reside with one employee, consultant, or vendor. These conditions can make a promising system difficult to integrate, use, or sustain.

Wood-products research shows that digital adoption depends on more than access to technology. Skills, infrastructure, integration, training, planning, and expected return all influence whether a given technology can be sustained.


The people who do the work should be involved early. Operators, graders, maintenance personnel, foresters, and managers often know where processes break down and what information would realistically help. Their knowledge is part of the evidence needed to decide whether a technology investment fits the operation.


COUNT THE FULL COST AND THE FULL VALUE

Purchase price is only part of the investment. Implementation also consumes staff time, management attention, training, data preparation, technical support, maintenance, and sometimes additional equipment or software. Once committed to the technology, those resources are no longer available for other operating, workforce, or capital needs; that tradeoff is part of the cost.

Value deserves the same scrutiny. In a mill, it may include greater yield, less downtime, better quality, improved safety, more consistent production, or reduced dependence on hard-to-fill positions. An investment makes sense when those gains are meaningful, durable, and large enough to justify the full implementation burden.


RESPONSIBILITY REMAINS HUMAN

AI can support a decision, but the people and organization using it remain accountable for the consequences. Before putting a system into use, the business should establish who will review its results and who has authority to question, override, or stop its operation. Testing and oversight should reflect the seriousness of a potential error and how difficult it would be to reverse its consequences. For example, employees reviewing a computer display of daily lumber production can check questionable totals against mill records before acting. A system that directly influences worker safety, lumber grading, or production commitments requires more rigorous testing under operating conditions and closer oversight because errors can affect people, product value, or customer obligations before they are corrected. In either case, employees need a practical fallback plan to keep work moving when results are unreliable or software, sensors, networks, or other components fail.


The accompanying AI Investment Decision Tool for Hardwood Businesses condenses these considerations into six questions. You can use it to organize evidence and spot warning signs before committing capital, staff time, or decision authority. It is not a scorecard; the importance of each question will vary with the application and consequences of error.


A disciplined AI evaluation does not have to end with a purchase. The decision may be to adopt, test further, simplify, delay, or decline. Each can be sound when supported by evidence.

The objective is not to make a hardwood business look technologically sophisticated; it is to improve decisions and operations. Start with the problem, compare credible alternatives, account for cost and value, keep responsibility clear, and require the technology to earn its place.


Selected Sources

Bumgardner, M., and U. Buehlmann. 2022. A Preliminary Assessment of Industry 4.0 and Digitized Manufacturing in the North American Woodworking Industry. Forest Products Journal 72(1):67–73. https://doi.org/10.13073/FPJ-D-21-00064

Legg, B., B. Dorfner, S. Leavengood, and E. Hansen. 2021. Industry 4.0 Implementation in US Primary Wood Products Industry. Drvna Industrija 72(2):143–153. https://doi.org/10.5552/drvind.2021.2017

Subedi, B., S. H. Gautam, and L. LeBel. 2026. Artificial intelligence in the forest products supply chain: Current applications and open challenges. Forestry: An International Journal of Forest Research 99(2):cpag010. https://doi.org/10.1093/forestry/cpag010


By JASON A. HUBBART


AN AI INVESTMENT DECISION TOOL FOR HARDWOOD BUSINESSES
QUESTION
LOOK FOR
WARNING SIGN
1. What decision or problem are we trying to improve?
How the decision is made now; who is re-sponsible; current performance; the cost or consequences of errors; and a measurable improvement that would justify change.
The project starts with the technology and then searches for a problem or use that might justify it.
2. Is AI or advanced analytics the best method?
Evidence comparing AI or advanced analytics with realistic alternatives, such as equipment calibration, better sensors, process redesign, existing software, conventional analytics, employee training, or expert judgment.
The proposed technology adds cost or complexity without showing that it will improve the decision more than a simpler alternative.
3. Are the data fit for the decision?
Data are accurate, consistent, timely, and relevant to the decision; there are enough observations to support the analysis; the data represent the products, species, equipment, or operating conditions involved; and access, ownership, security, and data gaps are clear.
Large amounts of data are available, but the data do not adequately represent the specific products, equip-ment, conditions, or decision the technology is expected to address.
4. Can the proposed technology work reliably in routine opera-tions?
Compatibility with existing equipment and software; timely delivery of results to support the decision; workforce training; internal or vendor support; maintenance; continuity if key personnel leave; and a practical backup process.
A prototype works in a demonstration or test, but the technology cannot be integrated, supported, maintained, or used reliably during routine production or field operations.
5. Does the expected value justify the full cost?
Expected effects on yield, downtime, quality, safety, labor, and consistency compared with capital cost, staff time, training, data prepara-tion, software, maintenance, and other investments the organization would defer.
The return-on-investment estimate counts expected benefits but ignores implementation burden, ongoing support costs, or competing uses of capital and staff time.
6. Who remains ac-countable, and what happens if the technology produces an incorrect output or stops functioning?
A named decision owner; human review and override authority; monitoring to detect declining performance; plans for inaccurate outputs, software or hardware outages, and vendor dependence; a backup workflow; and criteria for suspending or retiring the technology.
No one can explain who can ques-tion, stop, or override the technol-ogy, what happens when its output is wrong or it stops working, or how the operation will continue without it.

FedEx
FedEx
bottom of page